For many Christian pastors and preachers, spanking kids is an open and closed case. It’s in the Bible, right? (That announcement actually isn’t in the Bible) This is a command from God. Great parents are commanded to do it. Anyone who doesn’t do it is not after God’s word. Here is the proof. Only look these passages in the Bible.Proverbs 19:18Proverbs 13:24Proverbs 22:15Proverbs 23:13,14Case closed.Not too fast.Take the first passage,”Chasten thy son while there is hope, and let not thy soul spare for his crying.” (Proverbs 19:18 KJV). This teaching seems so clear until you take a look at it in more scholarly Bible versions. Scholars show wariat.org us that this is a really inadequate notion of what the original Hebrew text communicates.A fantastic example of this is the English Standard Version of the Bible which says:”Discipline your son, for there is hope; do not put your heart on putting him to death.” A very big difference. Other more modern variants concur with this later one.What about Proverbs 13:24? “He that spareth his rod hateth his son: but he that loveth him chasteneth him betimes.” (KJV) Sounds clear once again: Kids should be spanked.However, in early times, boys were treated differently than girls and this text is directed at men. That is exactly what Dr. E. W. Bullinger, editor of the Companion Bible said (Appendix 74):”They [the teachings in the book of Proverbs] were for men in general to learn” The Identical thought is echoed by Dr. John J. Pilch, of Georgetown University, in an article saying:”The majority of the parenting advice in Sirach (another historical book) and Proverbs concerns’sons’ or is treated to men.” What about Proverbs 22:15? “Foolishness is bound in the heart of a child; but the rod of correction will drive it far from him. (KJV) Seems once again very apparent, but there are nine distinct Hebrew words that describe different stages in the life of children and also the one used in this verse for kid definitely does not in an overall sense refer to very small children. “Withhold not correction from the child: for if thou beatest him with the rod, he shall not die. Thou shalt beat him with the rod, and shalt deliver his soul from hell.” (KJV)With this advice it’s simple to see why well-intentioned Bible believers state we need to spank our children to save them from hell.But this word translated as”hell” doesn’t signify that an ever-burning hell fire. This is exactly what the great Christian theologian and scholar H.A. Ironside pointed out in his comment on the book of Proverbs. Commenting on this specific verse in question, he said:”Sheol (this word is translated’hell’ in the verse referenced above) isn’t precisely hell. It’s the world of the souls .” Another notable Christian commentator on the book of Proverbs describes the passage and specifically avoids using the phrase”hell” in this verse. He does so because using the phrase”hell” does not correctly reflect what the original language instructs. Notice the following:”Thou shalt beat him with the rod, and shalt deliver his soul from Sheol.” (Kidner 1964)In short, this passage does not necessarily mean especially what lots of well intentioned Bible believers inform us it signifies.When we consider what theological scholars and more modern Bible versions are instructing us, lots of the notions about spanking kids, that can be considered as foregone conclusions and tried and examined Bible wisdom, become teachings which actually aren’t so clear whatsoever.What is required is a greater evaluation of the Biblical texts to make sure when it comes to issues that affect little children, we have to make extra double certain we are using the best possible tools and tools to evaluate ancient writings which were made in times very different than our own.In doing this, we may even realize that matters which we thought were clear and plain are in fact not that way whatsoever and we might need to rethink even precious teachings that we hold dear and believe are true, particularly if we discover that our beliefs don’t square with the facts.Samuel Martin writes historical subjects relating to this Bible from Jerusalem. His interests include: history, archaeology, science and the Bible, parenting, kids, kid rearing, mother/father/child relations, Biblical studies, Hebrew language and many other subjects.